| Rev. George McBrearty 1862-71 |
| Rev. Thomas Moran 1874-74 |
| Rev. Jean M. Crotius 1878-79 |
| Rev. Robert Grant 1889-89 |
| Rev. Edmund Cotter 1890-93 |
| Rev. Thomas Dooley 1898-1900 |
| Rev. George Lillis 1905-08 |
| Rev. Patrick Hallinan 1912-19 |
| Rev. Patrick Deeney 1919-23 |
| Rev. Edward Bradley 1923-26 |
| Rev. Thomas J. O'Kane 1927-46 |
| Rev. Jeremiah Healey 1936-44 |
| Rev. John Deans 1946-47 |
| Rev. Christopher Condon 1949-53 |
| Rev. James J. Ashe 1953-57 |
| Rev. Niall P. Hayes 1958-65 |
| Rev. Thomas Trench 1967-77 |
| Rev. James McGlinchey 1972-84 |
| Rev. Humphrey O'Mahoney 1984-84 |
| Rev. Richard J. Rogers 1985-86 |
| Rev. Gerard H. Maguinness 1996-99 |
| Rev. James Gilmour 1871-75 |
| Rev. Patrick J. O'Gorman 1875-77 |
| Rev. John Black 1887-89 |
| Rev. Louis W. Kuhler 1889-91 |
| Rev. Edward Doody 1894-96 |
| Rev. James Leonard 1900-12 |
| Rev. Patrick Gaynor 1911-11 |
| Rev. Robert Cairns 1912-21 |
| Rev. Thomas J. Murray 1921-33 |
| Rev. Bartholomew Atkinson 1926-27 |
| Rev. Alexander Mackintosh 1933-35 |
| Rev. Daniel O'Doherty 1944-58 |
| Rev. Denis Garrity 1947-49 |
| Rev. Francis T. Misset 1953-53 |
| Rev. Andrew Reen 1957-68 |
| Rev. Michael B. Maher 1965-66 |
| Rev. John McMurray 1968-72 |
| Rev. James Morris 1977-83 |
| Rev. John Docherty 1984-88 |
| Rev. Thomas G. Devine 1986-96 |
| Rev. Christopher Morris 2024-24 |
